Millions of college graduates who saw a degree as their ticket to a good-paying career and a secure life are working in jobs that do not require their education or even a high school diploma, sometimes leaving them with small wages to pay thousands in student loan debt, according to a new study.
About 48 percent of all working college alumni — not just recent graduates — were underemployed in 2010 as the United States began a slow recovery from the Great Recession, including 5 million graduates in jobs that require less than a high school diploma, according to a study from the Center for College Affordability and Productivity.
“The economy may be in recovery officially, but there are a lot of people who haven’t recovered yet,” said Jonathan Robe, one of three researchers on the report, “Why Are Recent College Graduates Underemployed.” “This is a problem that’s sticking around.”
When so many graduates are working in retail sales and as bartenders, janitors and maids, the study calls into question the appropriateness of extra spending to reach broad goals for more Americans to earn college degrees. President Barack Obama has charged that the U.S. lead the world in degree holders with 10 million more graduates by 2020. It also suggests that the underemployment problem is not going away because there is a growing disconnect between what employers need and the volume and nature of the training of college students.
Still, others say the data is looking back to the effects of one of the worst recessions America has ever seen. The Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce forecasts that 63 percent of all jobs will require some postsecondary education by 2018 — and the U.S. is on track to fall short of that need by 3 million workers.
“You’ve got to look to the future,” said Wright State University President David Hopkins. “In the next decade, they anticipate 31 million jobs being produced in the country that require education beyond high school. Don’t we want Ohioans to be prepared to fill those jobs?”
An estimated 57 percent of new jobs in Ohio that will be open through 2018 will require a college degree, and only about 36 percent of working-age Ohioans presently have degrees, according to the Lumina Foundation.
‘Discouraging’ and ‘disheartening’
Underemployment locally has left college graduates struggling to pay their student loans, working multiple jobs to make ends meet, and facing the possibility of life without health insurance — and little hope things will change soon.
Jessica Stringfield, who graduated from Miami University in 2011 with a degree in journalism and political science, has until March to find a job offering health insurance to pay for her insulin before she turns 26 and is no longer eligible to be on her mother’s health care plan. With four interviews this month and no job offers, she said the search is scary.
“I know I have a flawless resume, amazing letters of recommendation, a wonderful college degree and perfect interview skills, so it’s a very perplexing, discouraging situation to be in,” said Stringfield, who now works as an administrative assistant for a small dance studio that doesn’t offer her benefits. “Without insurance, my medication runs over $1,000 a month. There is no possible way I can afford that.”
Ohio University graduate Joe Brotherton, 25, had a job lined up at a law firm when he graduated with a political science degree in 2009. But so close to the economy’s collapse, the firm had to cut back and told him, “luckily you’re not losing a job, you’re just not going to get it.”
“That was pretty devastating,” said Brotherton, who is from Monroe.
After that, he took a job at Home Depot and has now worked his way up to be a department supervisor, earning benefits and just enough to cover his $800 a month student loan payment.
Brotherton said he is appreciative of his job, but he often thinks: “If I would have started at 18 instead of going to college, I would be doing really well for myself because I wouldn’t be in debt and I would be making even more money.”
He continues to look for a job that would utilize his degree or pay more, but “it’s hard to get your foot in the door,” he said. He’s given up the plan he had to attend law school because of the extra debt he would incur.
“It’s really disheartening,” he said. “I just want the chance to live a successful life. When the job market crashed, it’s not there anymore.”
Jobs require degrees are growing
Another consequence of college graduate underemployment is that high school graduates and drop outs are being displaced from jobs because employers will often hire the candidate with a degree even if the job doesn’t require it, Robe said.
People who attend college must focus on studying in a field that will lead to a job with a competitive wage, Robe said. According to the Georgetown study, many of the new jobs that will require postsecondary education are in information service, financial services and health care.
Hopkins said families and students must also look past the “rhetoric,” “malarkey” and extreme stories of student debt when they are considering higher education. In Ohio, he said, there are a variety of schools and affordable pathways to earn a college degree through institutions such as Wright State and community colleges.
There is also evidence that a college degree protects, at least to some degree, against unemployment. Nearly four out of every five jobs eliminated during the recession were held by high school graduates or drop outs, and those jobs continue to disappear during the recovery, according to Georgetown.
At the same time, nearly 200,000 jobs were added for people with a bachelor’s degree during the recession and 2 million more have been added during the recovery, Georgetown found.
University of Dayton graduate Gina Gerhart said she will never regret going to college, even though she has struggled to find a full-time job in her field since graduating in 2011 with a degree in communication and English, with a concentration in journalism.
“Graduating from college, it’s a huge accomplishment,” said Gerhart, who now works part-time at a YMCA in Akron. “It never looks bad to have a college degree.”